HORL makes the best-known rolling knife sharpener, and for a kitchen full of ordinary chef’s knives, santokus and paring knives it is one of the easiest ways to get a clean edge without learning a whetstone. The catch is that every HORL model shares the same limits: no serrated knives, no single-bevel Japanese knives, and slow going on a blade that is badly worn or chipped.
Which model you need depends on how far you want to take it. For most kitchens I recommend the HORL3 Cruise. The HORL 3 is the one to buy if you’d like a ceramic honing disc and the option of whetstone discs later.
My Top 5 HORL Picks
A fixed diamond disc, a steel honing disc and the new grippier magnetic support. It does the job most people buy a HORL for, and nothing in a normal knife block asks for more.
The full HORL 3: the same faster diamond disc as the Cruise, but a ceramic honing disc with grooves that clear grinding dust, and a roller that takes HORL’s whetstone discs if you get serious.
The model that made HORL famous is still sold: diamond and ceramic discs, ball-bearing roller, walnut body. A sound choice if you already own HORL 2 accessories.
A planetary gear inside the roller turns the disc three times for every turn of your hand. That only pays off if you sharpen a lot of knives in one sitting.
What HORL Does Well
The angle is set for you
The magnetic angle support is the clever part. The knife clamps to a face cut at 15 or 20 degrees, and the roller rides the counter at a fixed height, so every pass grinds at the same angle. That one feature removes the skill most people never learn on a stone.
Diamonds that cope with hard steel
Every HORL ships with a diamond grinding disc, and diamond cuts hard Japanese steel as readily as softer German steel. HORL says the newer HORL 3 diamonds remove up to 80% more steel than the HORL 2 version, which speaks directly to the most common complaint about rolling sharpeners.
Built in Germany by a family company
HORL was founded in Freiburg in 2016 by Otmar Horl and his son Timo, and its listings say the sharpeners are made in Germany, in the Black Forest. The wooden rollers are heavy, smooth and good-looking enough to keep on the counter, which matters more than it sounds: a sharpener you can see gets used.
No water, oil or mess
You use a HORL dry. There is no stone to soak, no slurry and no flattening, so a two-minute touch-up before dinner is realistic.
What HORL Does Badly
Two angles on most models
The Cruise, HORL 3 and HORL 2 give you 15 or 20 degrees and nothing else. That covers most kitchen knives, but a knife ground at 17 degrees will slowly be reshaped to one of the two. Only the top model, the HORL 3 Pro, adds more angles.
Not a repair tool
Turning a roller by hand removes steel slowly. A chipped edge or a knife that has gone years without care takes a long time, and a coarse whetstone or a sharpening service is the faster fix.
Straight edges only
Serrated bread knives, single-bevel knives such as a yanagiba or deba, and strongly recurved blades don’t suit the design. The disc needs a straight or gently curved double-bevel edge to follow.
The price of the name
You are paying for German manufacturing and a polished product. Rolling kits from other brands copy the same geometry for much less money, and for a couple of inexpensive knives that is hard to argue with.
HORL Models Compared
| Model | Grinding disc | Honing disc | Angles | Discs swappable | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HORL3 Cruise | HORL 3 diamond (fixed) | Stainless steel | 15° and 20° | No | Plain kitchen maintenance |
| HORL 3 | HORL 3 diamond | Grooved ceramic | 15° and 20° | Yes (HORL 3 whetstone discs) | Cooks who may refine edges later |
| HORL 2 | Diamond | Ceramic | 15° and 20° | Yes (HORL 2 discs) | Owners of HORL 2 accessories |
| HORL 2 Pro | Diamond, 1:3 planetary gear | Ceramic | 15° and 20° | Yes | Sharpening many knives at once |
| HORL 3 Pro | Diamond, geared | Ceramic | Six, 10° to 25° | Yes | Fine-tuning angles |
1. HORL3 Cruise Rolling Knife Sharpener: Best HORL for Most Kitchens
Who it’s for: anyone who wants a HORL to keep a normal set of kitchen knives sharp and has no plans to tinker.
The Cruise is the stripped-down HORL 3, and the parts it strips out are the parts most people never use. You still get the new HORL 3 diamond disc, which is the biggest upgrade over the old generation, and the magnetic support with HORL’s grip pad, which the company says holds knives with up to 70% more grip than before. That helps with short paring knives that used to slide around.
What you give up is flexibility. The diamond disc is permanently fixed, so there is no path to whetstone discs, and the honing side is stainless steel rather than ceramic. Steel honing straightens and cleans the burr well enough for German knives and most Japanese ones; ceramic leaves a slightly finer finish.
I’ve long argued on this site that you don’t need the expensive version of a tool to get the job done, and the Cruise is a good example. It gives you the HORL 3 grind at the bottom of the range.
Key specs
- Grinding: HORL 3 diamond disc, permanently fixed
- Honing: stainless steel disc
- Angles: 15° and 20° on a magnetic support with grip pad
- Used dry, no water or oil
- Made in Germany
Pros
- Same faster diamond grind as the HORL 3
- Grip pad holds small knives better
- Nothing to set up or replace
Cons
- Fixed disc, so no whetstone upgrades
- Steel honing disc is coarser than ceramic
- Still only two angles
My verdict: the HORL I’d hand to a busy home cook. If you can already picture yourself buying extra discs, step up to the HORL 3 instead.
2. HORL 3 Rolling Knife Sharpener (Walnut): Best Upgradeable HORL
Who it’s for: cooks with good Japanese or Damascus knives who want a finer finish and room to grow.
The HORL 3 is the current standard model, and the difference from the Cruise sits on the honing end. Instead of steel, you get a ceramic disc with grooves that carry grinding dust away from the blade. Ceramic refines the edge a little further and cleans up the burr on hard steel more neatly.
The bigger reason to choose it is the swappable disc system. HORL sells fine and extra-fine whetstone discs for the HORL 3 range, and retailers note they don’t fit the HORL 2. If you think rolling sharpening could turn into a small hobby, this is the roller to start on.
The walnut version is the one most people pick; HORL also makes it in oak, with the same insides.
Key specs
- Grinding: HORL 3 diamond disc (up to 80% more steel removal than HORL 2, per HORL)
- Honing: grooved ceramic disc
- Angles: 15° and 20° magnetic support with grip pad
- Accepts HORL 3 whetstone discs (sold separately)
- Walnut body, made in Germany
Pros
- Finer honing than the Cruise
- Upgrade path to whetstone discs
- Faster diamond grind than any HORL 2
Cons
- Costs more than the Cruise for the same angles
- Extra discs add up
My verdict: the HORL to buy once and keep adding to. For basic upkeep of a German knife block, the Cruise does the same job.
3. HORL 2 Rolling Knife Sharpener (Walnut): Best Classic HORL
Who it’s for: buyers who already own HORL 2 discs, or who want the proven model with a ceramic hone.
The HORL 2 is the sharpener most reviews and videos online are about, and it remains a capable tool. A diamond disc grinds, a ceramic disc hones, precision ball bearings keep the roll smooth, and the kiln-dried walnut body is made in the Black Forest.
The honest problem is that the HORL 3 is better in the two ways that matter: its diamonds grind faster and its support grips small knives harder. So I’d only choose the HORL 2 for a specific reason. The best one is accessories: HORL 2 discs don’t move to the HORL 3, so if you already have a drawer of them, staying on the HORL 2 makes sense.
Key specs
- Grinding: diamond disc
- Honing: ceramic disc
- Angles: 15° and 20° magnetic support
- Interchangeable discs (HORL 2 system)
- Walnut body, ball-bearing roller, made in Germany
Pros
- Ceramic honing included
- Smooth, solid roller
- Works with existing HORL 2 accessories
Cons
- Slower diamond than the HORL 3
- Older magnetic support grips small knives less firmly
My verdict: still a good sharpener, but a new buyer with no HORL 2 discs should go for the HORL 3 or the Cruise.
4. HORL 2 Pro Rolling Knife Sharpener: Best for Big Knife Collections
Who it’s for: people who sharpen a whole block, or a friend’s knives too, in one go.
The Pro looks like a HORL 2 but hides a planetary gear in the roller. HORL gives the ratio as 1:3: for every turn of the wooden body, the disc turns three times, so each pass does about three times the grinding. On a dull chef’s knife that turns a slow chore into a short one.
For one or two knives a month, the gear is a luxury. It doesn’t change the angles, it doesn’t add serrated support, and it costs much more than any other HORL here. It makes sense for a household with a dozen knives or for someone who sharpens for family and friends.
Key specs
- Planetary gear, 1:3 ratio (about three times faster per HORL)
- Grinding: diamond disc; honing: ceramic disc
- Angles: 15° and 20° magnetic support
- Made in Germany
Pros
- Fastest HORL in this list
- Most useful on very dull knives
- Same simple motion as the others
Cons
- Costs much more than the HORL 3
- Older HORL 2 support and disc system
My verdict: worth it only for volume. Most homes will never notice the gear’s benefit enough to justify it.
5. HORL Leather Strop: Best HORL Add-On
Who it’s for: any HORL owner who wants a smoother, longer-lasting edge.
A honing disc leaves a tiny wire of steel on the edge, and the strop pulls it off. HORL’s is a block of vegetable-tanned cowhide, hand-finished in the Black Forest, and its instructions match how I’d use any strop: light pressure, edge trailing, always moving the blade toward the spine. My guide on how to strop a knife explains why the direction matters. If you sharpen other ways too, my best leather strop guide covers standalone strops.
It works with every HORL generation and with a whetstone too, so it won’t be wasted if you change sharpeners. It can’t sharpen a dull knife on its own; it only finishes an edge that is already there.
Key specs
- Vegetable-tanned cowhide, hand-finished in Germany
- For HORL 3, HORL3 Cruise, HORL 3 Pro and HORL 2
- Also usable after whetstone sharpening
Pros
- Cleans off burr the honing disc leaves
- Fits any sharpening routine
- Small enough for a drawer
Cons
- No compound included, so polishing is gentle
- Adds a step some people will skip
My verdict: the add-on worth buying with any HORL. Skip it only if you know you won’t take the extra minute.
HORL vs Tumbler, Work Sharp and a Whetstone
HORL vs Tumbler: the same idea, a magnetic angle block and a hand-rolled disc. HORL created the format and builds in Germany; Tumbler sells more variations, including a mini model for small blades. For a block of kitchen knives, either brand does the job.
HORL vs Work Sharp: Work Sharp’s rolling sharpener ships with four preset angles, and its guided systems let you choose almost any angle. If your knives span several angles, that flexibility matters more than HORL’s build quality. My knife sharpener guide compares the main sharpener types side by side.
HORL vs a whetstone: a stone handles every angle, every edge repair and single-bevel knives, and costs less, but it takes practice. A HORL gets a beginner to a good edge on day one. Plenty of people end up owning both: the HORL for weekly touch-ups and a stone for repairs.
Picking the Right Angle and Disc on a HORL
Use 20 degrees unless the knife says otherwise
Most German, American and budget kitchen knives are ground near 20 degrees per side, and 20 is the tougher edge. Use 15 for Japanese and thin Damascus knives; my guide to sharpening Shun knives covers why those blades suit the lower angle.
Grind until you feel a burr, then switch
Roll the diamond side along the edge until a slight burr forms along the whole length on the opposite side, then flip the knife and repeat. Switch to the honing disc only once the burr runs heel to tip; honing a half-sharpened edge gives you a shiny dull knife.
Hone more often than you grind
A few passes on the honing disc every couple of weeks keeps the edge working, and the diamond side only comes out every few months. That routine also makes the slow-grind complaint mostly disappear, because the knife never gets very dull.
Check the result before you put it away
Slice a sheet of paper or a ripe tomato. My guide on telling if a knife is sharp enough has a few quick tests that don’t involve your thumb.
FAQ
Is the HORL knife sharpener worth it?
Yes, if you want consistently sharp kitchen knives without learning a whetstone and you value a well-made German tool. It is not worth it for serrated or single-bevel knives, or if a cheaper rolling kit already does what you need.
What is the difference between HORL 2 and HORL 3?
The HORL 3 has faster block diamonds (up to 80% more steel removal, according to HORL) and a magnetic support with a grip pad that holds knives more firmly. Its discs and accessories don’t fit the HORL 2, and HORL 2 discs don’t fit the HORL 3.
Which HORL should I buy?
The HORL3 Cruise for simple upkeep, the HORL 3 if you want a ceramic hone and whetstone discs later, and the HORL 2 Pro only if you sharpen many knives at once. The HORL 2 makes sense mainly for people who already own its discs.
Can a HORL sharpen pocket knives?
Many plain-edge pocket and outdoor knives work on the 20 degree side, and HORL lists outdoor and pocket knives for the Cruise. Very short blades, recurves and serrated sections are awkward on any rolling sharpener.
Does HORL work on Japanese knives?
Yes, for double-bevel Japanese knives such as a gyuto or santoku: use the 15 degree side. Single-bevel knives like a yanagiba need a whetstone.
How long do HORL discs last?
For home use, the diamond disc lasts a very long time because a rolling sharpener removes little steel per session. Honing discs wear faster, but on a household routine they are rarely a regular cost.
Final Verdict
The HORL3 Cruise is the HORL I recommend to most people: the new faster diamond, the grippier support and nothing you’ll never use. Choose the HORL 3 if you want ceramic honing and the option of whetstone discs, and keep the HORL 2 Pro for households that sharpen a lot of knives in one session. Whatever you buy, add the leather strop.
Want to see how rolling sharpeners compare with electric and guided ones? My gyuto sharpening guide walks through the whetstone route, and how to sharpen WÜSTHOF knives covers German blades on every kind of sharpener.

Gary Portman founded knivesadvice.com in 2019. He learned to cook in his family’s kitchen as a kid and has used kitchen, pocket and outdoor knives ever since, from paring and fillet knives to survival blades he carries camping and hiking. He writes the site’s buying guides, brand reviews and sharpening how-tos to help readers find the right knife for the job. More about Gary.




