Old Timer Knives Review 2026: 6 Sawcut Classics Still Worth a Pocket

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Old Timer knives are still good value if you want a traditional pocket knife or a small hunting knife that costs very little and comes with a lifetime warranty. They are not the knives your grandfather carried, though. Production left New York in 2004 and moved to Asia, and the steel and finish now match the price rather than the legend.

The one I’d buy first isn’t a folder at all: it’s the Old Timer 152OT Sharpfinger, a fixed blade skinner that has stayed in the line for about fifty years because the shape simply works. For a classic pocket knife, the 8OT Senior is the pick.

My Top 6 Old Timer Picks

Old Timer 8OT Senior 6.9in S.S. Traditional Folding Knife with 3in Clip Point, Sheepsfoot, Spey Blade and Sawcut Handle for Outdoor, Hunting, Camping and EDC
Best Three-Blade Stockman
Old Timer 8OT Senior

The pocket knife that comes to mind first with the name “Old Timer”: clip, sheepsfoot and spey blades in a brown sawcut handle. Three blade shapes for the chores of a normal day.

Old Timer 94OTY Gunstock Trapper 6.9in S.S. Traditional Folding Knife with 3in Clip Point Blade and Yellow Handle for Outdoor, Hunting, Camping and EDC
Best Two-Blade Trapper
Old Timer 94OTY Gunstock Trapper, Yellow

Two long blades in a slim gunstock frame, with a yellow handle you can actually find when you drop it in the grass. A light, simple carry knife.

Old Timer 6OT Golden Bear Traditional Lockback Pocket Knife with 3.9in High Carbon Stainless Steel Clip Point Blade, Sawcut Handle, and Lanyard Hole for Hunting, Whittling, Camping, EDC, and Outdoors
Best Lockback
Old Timer 6OT Golden Bear

A big clip point blade that locks open, for anyone who doesn’t trust a slipjoint on harder work. It feels like a working knife, not a keepsake.

Old Timer Heritage Pocket Knife 2.4" Clip Point D2 Tool Steel Polished Blade Laminated Wood Handle Black/Gray
Best Steel Upgrade
Old Timer Heritage Middleman, D2

The classic three-blade Middleman layout with D2 steel and a laminated wood handle. It holds an edge longer than the standard Old Timer steel.

Old Timer Generational USA Series 152OTG Sharpfinger Fixed Blade Knife with Stainless Steel Clip Point Skinner Blade, Bone Handle, and Made in USA for Hunting, Skinning, Field Dressing and Outdoors
Best Made in USA
Old Timer Generational USA 152OTG Sharpfinger

The same Sharpfinger shape built in the USA with a bone handle. The one to give someone who remembers the old American Old Timers.

What Old Timer Does Well

Classic patterns at a low price

Old Timer started as a Schrade-Walden line in the late 1950s, and the core patterns are still here: Senior stockman, Middleman, gunstock trapper, Golden Bear lockback, Sharpfinger and Deerslayer. If you want a traditional knife with nickel silver bolsters and a sawcut handle, few brands sell one for less.

A lifetime warranty

Every pick on this page is listed as covered by Old Timer’s lifetime warranty. On knives this inexpensive, that’s a nice extra: a loose spring or a cracked handle from a factory flaw is the company’s problem, not yours.

Shapes that suit hunters

The Sharpfinger and the spey blades on the Senior and the trapper were drawn for field dressing and skinning. Plenty of hunters who own expensive knives still keep a Sharpfinger in the pack because the short, curved blade is easy to control inside a deer.

What Old Timer Does Badly

It isn’t the American Old Timer anymore

Imperial Schrade closed its Ellenville, New York factory in 2004. Taylor Brands bought the Schrade, Old Timer, Uncle Henry and Imperial names, and production moved to Asia, mainly China. Collectors who grew up with USA-made Old Timers often find the new ones disappointing. Only the Generational USA series on this page is made in the USA. If made in USA matters to you, my American-made knives guide has more choices.

Ordinary steel and rough factory edges

Most current Old Timers are listed simply as “high carbon stainless steel,” a budget grade that sharpens easily but doesn’t hold an edge long. The complaint I see most from owners is a factory edge that needs work before the first real job, plus springs and blades that vary from one knife to the next. A few minutes on a stone fixes the edge; it won’t fix a gappy spring.

No locks, no clips on the classics

The Senior, Middleman and trapper are slip joint knives: a back spring keeps tension on the blade, yet there’s no lock. Push the wrong way and it folds. My folding knife lock types guide explains the difference. If you want a lock, choose the Golden Bear or another lockback.

Old Timer Lines Compared

Model Type Blades Main blade Handle Best for
152OT Sharpfinger Fixed blade 1 3.3″ Sawcut Delrin Skinning and field dressing
152OTG Sharpfinger (Generational USA) Fixed blade 1 3.5″ Bone US-made gift or heirloom
15OT Deerslayer Fixed blade 1 5.6″ Sawcut Delrin Camp and big game
8OT Senior Slipjoint stockman 3 3″ Sawcut All-round traditional carry
34OT Middleman / Heritage D2 Slipjoint stockman 3 2.15 to 2.4″ Sawcut, bone or laminated wood Smaller pockets
94OT Gunstock Trapper Slipjoint trapper 2 3″ Sawcut or yellow Light two-blade carry
6OT Golden Bear Lockback 1 3.9″ Sawcut Harder cutting with a lock
18OT Mighty Mite Lockback 1 2″ Sawcut Delrin Tiny keychain or coin pocket knife

1. Old Timer 152OT Sharpfinger: Best Old Timer Overall

Schrade Old Timer Sharpfinger Knife | Handle, Leather Sheath - For Hunting, Camping, Outdoors

Check Price on Amazon

Who it’s for: deer and small game hunters who want a cheap, proven skinner, and anyone who wants one Old Timer that does a real job well.

The Sharpfinger has a 3.3 inch blade with a fine clip point and a strong upward sweep. That curve gives you a lot of cutting edge in a short blade, which is exactly what you want when you’re separating hide from meat. The thumb rise and finger choil let you choke up and work close to the tip.

It’s a full tang knife with sawcut Delrin scales and a brown leather belt sheath, and it weighs about 3 ounces. Because it’s a fixed blade, there’s no joint to collect blood and hair, so cleaning it after a hunt takes a minute under the tap.

What I’d warn you about: the upswept tip is great for skinning and less handy for general camp chores, and the leather sheath is basic. As a single do-it-all knife, a drop point is the more versatile shape.

Key specs

  • Blade: 3.3 inch clip point skinner, high carbon stainless steel
  • Overall length: 7.1 inches; weight: 3.1 oz
  • Handle: sawcut Delrin, full tang
  • Sheath: brown leather belt sheath
  • Old Timer lifetime warranty

Pros

  • Excellent skinning shape with good tip control
  • Full tang and easy to clean
  • Costs very little for what it does

Cons

  • Upswept tip is less useful for general chores
  • Basic leather sheath
  • Factory edge often needs touching up

My verdict: the best reason to buy an Old Timer today. Look elsewhere if you need a camp knife more than a skinner.


2. Old Timer 8OT Senior: Best Three-Blade Stockman

Old Timer 8OT Senior 6.9in S.S. Traditional Folding Knife with 3in Clip Point, Sheepsfoot, Spey Blade and Sawcut Handle for Outdoor, Hunting, Camping and EDC

Check Price on Amazon

Who it’s for: people who want the classic Old Timer pocket knife, as a first traditional knife, a farm knife or a gift.

The Senior is a stockman: a clip point for most cutting, a sheepsfoot with a flat edge and no real point for cutting cord or opening boxes safely, and a spey blade for skinning or for jobs where a sharp tip would get in the way. Each blade has its own nail nick, and the handle is the brown sawcut pattern with nickel silver pins and bolsters.

It’s the knife I’d point to if someone asked what Old Timer is about. It’s light at 2.8 ounces, and the main blade is 3 inches, which is long enough for food prep at a picnic and short enough to keep the knife unremarkable in a pocket.

The reservation is the same as with every slipjoint stockman: three blades make it thick, and new springs can be stiff. Don’t use it for prying.

Key specs

  • Blades: 3 inch clip point, sheepsfoot and spey, high carbon stainless steel
  • Overall length (open): 6.9 inches; weight: 2.8 oz
  • Handle: sawcut, nickel silver pins and bolsters
  • Slipjoint (no lock)
  • Old Timer lifetime warranty

Pros

  • Three useful blade shapes
  • Classic look that makes an easy gift
  • Light for its size

Cons

  • No lock and no clip
  • Thick in the pocket
  • Fit and spring tension vary between knives

My verdict: the Old Timer pocket knife to start with. If you never use more than one blade, the Golden Bear or the trapper makes more sense.


3. Old Timer 94OTY Gunstock Trapper, Yellow: Best Two-Blade Trapper

Old Timer 94OTY Gunstock Trapper 6.9in S.S. Traditional Folding Knife with 3in Clip Point Blade and Yellow Handle for Outdoor, Hunting, Camping and EDC

Check Price on Amazon

Who it’s for: anyone who wants a slim two-blade knife and keeps losing pocket knives outdoors.

A gunstock trapper has a handle shaped a little like a rifle stock, with a step near the bolster. This one carries a 3 inch clip point and a spey blade, both of which open from the same end. Two blades make it thinner than the Senior, and at 2.5 ounces it’s the lightest knife in my list.

I chose the yellow handle on purpose. A brown knife dropped in leaves or a dark truck floor can take a while to find; a yellow one doesn’t. That’s a practical reason, but it’s also the color many people remember from older trappers.

The downside is the same old slipjoint story, plus a smooth synthetic handle that is a bit slippery when wet. If you plan to use it mostly for skinning, the Sharpfinger is the better tool.

Key specs

  • Blades: 3 inch clip point and spey, high carbon stainless steel
  • Overall length (open): 6.9 inches; weight: 2.5 oz
  • Handle: yellow, nickel silver pins and bolsters
  • Slipjoint (no lock)
  • Old Timer lifetime warranty

Pros

  • Slim and light
  • Easy to spot when dropped
  • Two long, useful blades

Cons

  • No lock
  • Smooth handle can be slippery when wet

My verdict: a fine everyday traditional knife for light work. If you want three blades, choose the Senior.


4. Old Timer 6OT Golden Bear: Best Lockback

Old Timer 6OT Golden Bear Traditional Lockback Pocket Knife with 3.9in High Carbon Stainless Steel Clip Point Blade, Sawcut Handle, and Lanyard Hole for Hunting, Whittling, Camping, EDC, and Outdoors

Check Price on Amazon

Who it’s for: buyers who like the Old Timer look but want a blade that locks open for heavier cutting.

The Golden Bear is a big traditional lockback with a 3.9 inch clip point, brass bolsters and a lanyard hole. Once it’s open, a lock bar on the spine holds the blade until you press it to close, so the blade won’t fold onto your fingers if you push it the wrong way.

It’s a big knife: 8.7 inches open and almost 6 ounces. That makes it a belt or jacket knife more than a jeans pocket knife, and it’s the Old Timer I’d take for cutting rope, opening feed bags or camp kitchen work.

What I don’t love: it’s heavy for daily carry, there’s no clip, and the nail nick means two-hand opening. If you want a lockback in a size that disappears, the tiny Mighty Mite is the opposite extreme; for something in between, look at the folders in my best folding knives under $100 guide.

Key specs

  • Blade: 3.9 inch clip point, high carbon stainless steel
  • Overall length (open): 8.7 inches; weight: 5.9 oz
  • Handle: sawcut, brass bolsters, lanyard hole
  • Lock: lockback
  • Old Timer lifetime warranty

Pros

  • Blade locks open
  • Long blade for heavier jobs
  • Classic traditional styling

Cons

  • Heavy and long for pocket carry
  • Two-hand opening, no clip

My verdict: the Old Timer for work where a slipjoint feels risky. Too big if you want something you forget is there.


5. Old Timer Heritage Middleman, D2: Best Steel Upgrade

Old Timer Heritage Pocket Knife 2.4" Clip Point D2 Tool Steel Polished Blade Laminated Wood Handle Black/Gray

Check Price on Amazon

Who it’s for: people who like the Middleman size but don’t want to sharpen every week.

The Heritage series keeps the old patterns and changes the materials. This Middleman has three blades (clip point, sheepsfoot and pen) in D2 steel with a gray and black laminated wood handle. D2 is a tool steel with a lot of chromium, so its edge lasts clearly longer than on the standard Old Timer blades and resists rust fairly well, though it isn’t fully stainless.

It’s small: 5.7 inches open, a 2.15 inch main blade and under 2 ounces. That’s my idea of an office or dress-pants knife that still has a real edge on it.

The trade-off is that D2 takes longer to sharpen when it finally dulls, and small nail nicks on three blades are fiddly. It also costs more than the regular Middleman, though still very little for a three-blade knife.

Key specs

  • Blades: 2.15 inch clip point, sheepsfoot and pen, D2 steel
  • Overall length (open): 5.7 inches; weight: 1.79 oz
  • Handle: laminated wood, black and gray
  • Slipjoint (no lock)
  • Old Timer lifetime warranty

Pros

  • Holds an edge longer than standard Old Timer steel
  • Small and very light
  • Three blade shapes

Cons

  • Slower to sharpen than softer steel
  • Small blades are fiddly to open
  • No lock

My verdict: the smartest small Old Timer. Pick the Senior instead if you want a longer main blade.


6. Old Timer Generational USA 152OTG Sharpfinger: Best Made in USA

Old Timer Generational USA Series 152OTG Sharpfinger Fixed Blade Knife with Stainless Steel Clip Point Skinner Blade, Bone Handle, and Made in USA for Hunting, Skinning, Field Dressing and Outdoors

Check Price on Amazon

Who it’s for: buyers who want a US-made Old Timer, often as a gift for someone who carried one decades ago.

The Generational USA series is Old Timer’s answer to the “they’re not made here anymore” complaint. This Sharpfinger is listed as made in the USA, with a 3.5 inch blade, a sawcut bone handle, nickel silver bolsters and pins, a lanyard hole and a custom leather sheath.

Old Timer lists the blade as 1095 HC steel. 1095 is a carbon steel, so I’d treat it like one: dry it after use, give it a thin coat of oil once in a while, and expect it to turn gray with time. My carbon vs stainless steel guide explains what that means day to day.

My honest reservation: it costs much more than the standard Sharpfinger, and the blade does the same job. You’re paying for where it’s made and for the bone handle. If the knife is going into a muddy hunting pack, buy the regular one.

Key specs

  • Blade: 3.5 inch clip point skinner, 1095 HC steel (per listing)
  • Overall length: 7.25 inches; weight: 3.77 oz
  • Handle: sawcut bone, nickel silver bolsters and pins, full tang
  • Sheath: leather belt sheath; lanyard hole
  • Made in USA; Old Timer lifetime warranty

Pros

  • US-made, unlike most of the line
  • Bone handle with real heirloom appeal
  • Same proven skinning shape

Cons

  • Costs much more than the standard Sharpfinger
  • Carbon blade needs drying and oiling
  • Bone handle doesn’t like soaking

My verdict: the Old Timer to give as a keepsake. For a working skinner, the standard Sharpfinger is the better buy.

Old Timer vs Other Traditional Brands

Old Timer vs Case

Case still builds its slipjoints in Bradford, Pennsylvania, and offers far more handle options. Old Timer costs much less and has the better fixed blade skinner. For a knife to keep for life, choose Case; for a working knife you won’t cry over, choose Old Timer. My Bear & Son knives review covers another US-made traditional brand.

Old Timer vs Uncle Henry

Uncle Henry was the slightly fancier sister line under the same Schrade roof, known for Staglon handles and lockbacks like the Bear Paw and Smokey. Both brands come from the same owner today. Pick by pattern and handle you like, not by name.

Old Timer vs Buck

Buck’s lockbacks, like the 110, are heavier and more refined, and Buck still makes many knives in Idaho. If you want a lockback to rely on for years, Buck is the safer bet. If you want a traditional multi-blade pocket knife on a small budget, Old Timer gives you more patterns to choose from.

Old Timer vs cheap imports

Plenty of no-name sawcut trappers copy the Old Timer look. Old Timer at least backs its knives with a lifetime warranty and keeps the patterns consistent. Brands like the one in my Elk Ridge knives review sit in the same price range if you only want a gift knife.

Getting a New Old Timer Ready to Use

Expect to sharpen it. Before the first job, give each blade a few passes on a medium stone, then a fine one, holding the angle steady. My pocket knife sharpening guide walks through the steps, including how to handle a small pen blade.

Next, put a drop of light oil in each joint and work the blades open and closed a dozen times. Stiff springs loosen a little, and the oil keeps grit from wearing the pivot. Wipe the blades clean and dry before the knife goes back in your pocket. Keep the Sharpfinger’s leather sheath dry too, because wet leather against a blade invites rust spots.

FAQ

Are Old Timer knives still made in the USA?

Mostly no. Since the Schrade factory in New York closed in 2004, standard Old Timer knives have been made in Asia, mainly China. The Generational USA series is the exception and is listed as made in the USA.

Is Old Timer the same company as Schrade?

Old Timer began as a Schrade line, and the Schrade name, Old Timer, Uncle Henry and Imperial have stayed together under the same owner since 2004. Schrade-branded knives today are mostly modern folders and fixed blades, while Old Timer keeps the traditional patterns.

What steel do Old Timer knives use?

Most current models are listed as high carbon stainless steel, a budget stainless that sharpens easily but dulls sooner than premium steels. The Heritage series uses D2 on some models, and the Generational USA Sharpfinger is listed as 1095 HC.

What is the most popular Old Timer knife?

The 152OT Sharpfinger is the best known, along with the classic pocket patterns like the 8OT Senior, 34OT Middleman and 94OT Gunstock Trapper.

Do Old Timer knives have a warranty?

Yes. The listings for every knife on this page mention Old Timer’s lifetime warranty against defects. It doesn’t cover misuse or normal wear, so contact Old Timer’s customer service directly for a claim.

Are old USA-made Old Timer knives worth more?

Usually, yes. Pre-2004 Old Timers stamped Schrade USA are collected and often sell for more than new ones, especially in good condition with the original box. Value depends on the pattern and condition.

Final Verdict

Old Timer is a budget traditional brand now, and judged that way it’s a good one. The 152OT Sharpfinger is the knife I’d buy first because its skinning shape is still hard to beat. The 8OT Senior is the classic pocket knife, and the Heritage D2 Middleman is the small knife with better steel.

If you’d rather carry a modern folder with a clip and a lock, see my best EDC knives under $100, and for the brands I rate overall, my best knife makers list.

Leave a Comment